Is Creatine Bad for Your Kidneys? A Claim Analysis

One claim I’ve been seeing a lot on TikTok is that creatine is dangerous and can damage your kidneys. I’ve even had my mother tell me to stop taking creatine due to this fear. I included multiple TikTok videos where people warn others not to take creatine because it’s “bad for your body” or “hurts your kidneys.” Since I go to the gym regularly and creatine is one of the most popular supplements, this caught my attention. It’s something that directly relates to my routine, so I wanted to actually fact check it instead of just believing what I see online.

The first reason I was skeptical is because of how serious the claim sounds. Kidney damage is not a small issue, so if that were true, it would be a big deal. Another red flag was that all three TikTok videos I looked at didn’t provide any scientific sources. They were mostly opinions or quick warnings, which made me question their reliability. Because of this, I used a lateral reading approach SIFT method. I left TikTok and looked for more credible sources like medical websites and research studies.

My first step was to check the Mayo Clinic article. According to Mayo Clinic, creatine is “generally safe” when taken at recommended doses and does not appear to harm kidney function in healthy individuals. This goes against what the TikTok videos were saying. However, it also mentions that people with existing kidney disease should be cautious and talk to a doctor before using creatine. That helped me understand where some of the confusion and experiences might come from.

Next, I looked at the scientific study from PubMed. The research shows that creatine can slightly increase creatinine levels in the body, but this does not mean kidney damage is happening.  Creatinine is something doctors use to measure kidney function, so when levels go up, people might assume something is wrong. This misunderstanding is likely why the myth spreads so easily online.

To further verify the claim, I found a UCLA article that explains how creatine should be taken. Reviews of creatine show that when taken at recommended doses which is around 3–5 grams daily, it is safe for most people and does not negatively affect kidney function.  I also found that long term studies in healthy adults consistently show no harmful effects on the kidneys. 

I also considered why this claim is so popular. Social media tends to spread more dramatic or scary information because it gets more attention. Saying “creatine damages your kidneys” is more likely to go viral than explaining the full truth. Also, many people confuse correlation with causation. Just because something changes in the body like creatinine levels doesn’t automatically mean it’s harmful.

After going through all of these steps, my final conclusion is that the claim is misleading and mostly false. Creatine does not damage the kidneys in healthy individuals when taken correctly. However, it may not be suitable for people with preexisting kidney conditions, which is likely where the misunderstanding comes from.

This assignment made me realize how easy it is for misinformation to spread in the fitness world, especially on TikTok. A lot of advice is based on opinions instead of actual evidence. Taking a few extra minutes to check credible sources like medical websites or research studies can completely change your understanding of a claim. Instead of blindly following trends, it’s better to base decisions on real information. Especially when it comes to your health and what you put into your body.

https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZP8gkp95E

This is a TikTok of a man explaining what creatine does to your body within a 30 day spand when taken correctly.

https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZP8gkKaJ5

This TikTok is a Doctor from California debunking myths and answering questions about creatine.

https://www.tiktok.com/t/ZP8gk7Qwq

This is a TikTok of someone claiming creatine caused them kidney failure. The comments are turned off. This does not look reliable.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8228369

https://www.uclahealth.org/news/article/why-everyones-talking-about-creatine

https://www.mayoclinic.org/drugs-supplements-creatine/art-20347591

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *